When I sent this piece to our e-list I received a query/comment from Mark. I'm pasting it here, along with my response, as it would be reasonable that others may have the same thoughts. -- Jackie -- April 15th, 2003
Jackie,
How
do we know that the timing of this picture was not a significant amount of
time after the event when the masses have all gone home? Is it
the location of the armored vehicle and the position of the statue? I know
the statue was dragged around the square by said masses just
after it was toppled so maybe this is an easy question to
answer.
Just trying to play Devils advocate here to make sure the information youre sending isnt inaccurate. Mark Rexroad
Mark,
I watched a staged cheering rally allegedly by the people of Kuwait after
their "liberation" in the first Gulf War. I was very naive at that
time (1991) and KNEW then that the rally was
staged. The cheering and clapping and whistling was much greater
than the numbers of people there. A shoddy shot gave us a view of the
actual numbers in that "crowd". Are you aware that the Pentagon (I'll
say allegedly here, because today we can't believe ANYTHING we hear, read
or even 'see') threatened the lives of independent reporters in Iraq?
They DO NOT want you to know the truth. I cannot judge for you.
That must come from within you -- NOT from our 'logic', but from our
intuition. THAT is where the truth dwells. --
Jackie
P.S. Did you read Jim Condit's remarks at the bottom of the page I sent? It IS worthy of your read. -- J
Good
point Jackie. Its good to know that there is someone
plugged-in, as I say, like you are. Yes I did read Jims
remarks but I find that loosely gathered information, that is, information
presented without specific reference to source, is difficult to trust. I
understand that today, there is so little reference to rely on but someone
out there could do well to stay on top of all the stories and compile
similarities and contradictions to make the picture clearer
or foggier
depending upon the viewpoint.
I love your site and what you are doing. I pray that you will be able to continue the march without confronting a march-terminating obstacle. I share the information you send me to everyone who will listen, and the list is growing so keep up the good work! Mark
Just Another
Staged Baghdad
Rally?
|
This wide-angle photo by Reuters of the toppling of Saddam Hussein's statue in central Baghdad arouses suspicions that the "spontaneous jubilation" by the Iraqi masses shown on television around the world was a "media event" orchestrated by the Pentagon.
Rather than a spontaneous mass demonstration, the photo clearly shows that only a couple hundred Iraqis participated in the largely empty and heavily guarded Fardus Square. American tanks and troops surrounded the square and one armored vehicle "helped" the Iraqis pull down the statue. In the upper part of the photo, it appears that normal traffic into the square has been blocked by American troops. Conveniently, this square is in close proximity to the Palestine Hotel, which houses journalists covering the war. The timing of the activities is also suspicious; the wrecking of the statue occurred during the morning shows on the American television networks. The motive for this seemingly staged event: In the wake of reports of an ambivalent Iraqi reaction to an invasion billed as one designed to "liberate" Iraq, the Bush administration badly needed television pictures showing Iraqi popular support. Thanks to Information Clearing House for the source information and photo. Ivan Eland is Senior Fellow and Director of the Center on Peace & Liberty at The Independent Institute in Oakland, Calif., and author of the book, Putting "Defense" Back into U.S. Defense Policy: Rethinking U.S. Security in the Post-Cold War World. For further articles and studies, see the War on Terrorism.
Comments below by Jim Condit http://www.networkamerica.com/
The
toppling of the statue of Saddam Hussein in Baghdad was |
Back to Iraq main page | America's New War or War on Americans? | Issues Index | CDR Home |